INTERNATIONAL LAW EXPERT SAYS AMERICA HAS A DUTY TO SET HAWAI'I FREE
Hawaii Tribune-Herald - Thursday, December 30, 2004
By PETER SUR - Tribune-Herald staff writer
A professor of international law contends that the so-called Akaka Bill would strip Hawaiians of their right to self-determination. He also says independence would be best achieved through international law.
Speaking Wednesday afternoon at the University of Hawaii at Hilo, Francis A. Boyle, who teaches at the University of Illinois, offered an ominous
vision of the legislation that, as the bill states, would "provide a process for the recognition by the United States of the Native Hawaiian governing entity."
"Under the Akaka legislation, kanaka maoli (Native Hawaiians) are going to get an entity, not a government, not a state, just an entity, whatever that is," Boyle said.
Sovereignty, he said, would not be determined by the Hawaiians as declared in the "Apology Bill" - Congress' 1993 resolution apologizing for the overthrow of the Hawaiian Kingdom.
Instead, Boyle said the Akaka Bill would establish an "interim governing council" - a far cry from an actual government. It would have no authority to enact laws or control land, and would be subject to federal jurisdiction.
"The United States federal government is setting up a process whereby it's telling you, the kanaka maoli, how you are going to give up your sovereignty, give up your land and give up your self-determination."
He offered instead an alternative to the Akaka Bill - arguing the case in an international court of law. Boyle said the United States made numerous treaties with the Hawaiian Kingdom in the 19th century, none of which has since been rescinded.
Further, the Akaka bill and the Apology bill both recognize the Hawaiians have "never relinquished their claims" to sovereignty.
"They're trying to defeat and deny the right you had under international law, the right to self-determination, the right to reinstitution of these treaties, the right to the restoration of the Hawaiian Kingdom by saying, 'This is it. This will be your exercise of sovereignty, your exercise of self-determination and nothing more. You do what we tell you to do.'"
"The United States promised 'perpetual peace and amity' to the Hawaiian Kingdom," Boyle said, referring to an 1849 treaty. "That promise is still there. Even though the United States has not honored it, it is obligated to honor it."
