AWESOME AUSTRIA
Showing posts with label Stand For Mauna Kea. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Stand For Mauna Kea. Show all posts
Saturday, July 09, 2016
TMT NOW LOOKING FOR ALTERNATIVE SITES
Civil Beat - July 8, 2016
Following protests and a permit revocation, the Thirty Meter Telescope board is considering other places to build the project instead of the top of Mauna Kea, Physics World reported Friday.
“Hawaii is still an option but we are very actively looking at alternatives,” Fiona Harrison, Caltech physicist and member of TMT International Observatory’s governing board, told the publication.
“We’ll be culling down [the list of sites] to a few options over the summer.”
Civil Beat - July 8, 2016
Following protests and a permit revocation, the Thirty Meter Telescope board is considering other places to build the project instead of the top of Mauna Kea, Physics World reported Friday.
“Hawaii is still an option but we are very actively looking at alternatives,” Fiona Harrison, Caltech physicist and member of TMT International Observatory’s governing board, told the publication.
“We’ll be culling down [the list of sites] to a few options over the summer.”
Saturday, December 12, 2015
Saturday, December 05, 2015
Wednesday, December 02, 2015
FLASH! - HAWAI`I SUPREME COURT INVALIDATES TMT MAUNA KEA PERMIT
The Hawai`i state Supreme Court today invalidated the permit allowing construction of the Thirty Meter Telescope atop Mauna Kea.
The court said the state Board of Land and Natural Resources erred when it issued the permit before a contested case hearing was held for the $1.4 billion project.
“Quite simply, the board put the cart before the horse,” said the opinion written by Chief Justice Mark Recktenwald.
The court on Nov. 17 granted a request for an emergency stay that blocked crews from working at the TMT site through today, averting a confrontation with protesters who had planned to stop crews from performing vehicle maintenance and repair at the work site.
Today’s order could set back the project months to years while it goes through permitting again.
The Hawai`i state Supreme Court today invalidated the permit allowing construction of the Thirty Meter Telescope atop Mauna Kea.
The court said the state Board of Land and Natural Resources erred when it issued the permit before a contested case hearing was held for the $1.4 billion project.
“Quite simply, the board put the cart before the horse,” said the opinion written by Chief Justice Mark Recktenwald.
The court on Nov. 17 granted a request for an emergency stay that blocked crews from working at the TMT site through today, averting a confrontation with protesters who had planned to stop crews from performing vehicle maintenance and repair at the work site.
Today’s order could set back the project months to years while it goes through permitting again.
Tuesday, November 17, 2015
FLASH! - HAWAI`I SUPREME COURT GRANTS TEMPORARY SUSPENSION OF PERMIT FOR MAUNA KEA TELESCOPE
Associated Press - Honolulu - November 17, 2015
The Hawaii Supreme Court is temporarily suspending a permit that allows a giant telescope to be built on a mountain many Native Hawaiians consider sacred.
The court granted telescope opponents' request for an emergency stay of the effectiveness of the permit until December 2, or until another court order.
The ruling comes as protesters are gathering on Mauna Kea in anticipation of blocking telescope work from resuming. Work has been stalled since April amid the protests.
Telescope officials announced recently crew would return to the site this month to do vehicle maintenance work but they wouldn't specify a date.
Representatives for the project and the state attorney general's office didn't immediately comment on the ruling.
Associated Press - Honolulu - November 17, 2015
The Hawaii Supreme Court is temporarily suspending a permit that allows a giant telescope to be built on a mountain many Native Hawaiians consider sacred.
The court granted telescope opponents' request for an emergency stay of the effectiveness of the permit until December 2, or until another court order.
The ruling comes as protesters are gathering on Mauna Kea in anticipation of blocking telescope work from resuming. Work has been stalled since April amid the protests.
Telescope officials announced recently crew would return to the site this month to do vehicle maintenance work but they wouldn't specify a date.
Representatives for the project and the state attorney general's office didn't immediately comment on the ruling.
Saturday, October 17, 2015
Friday, October 16, 2015
Saturday, October 10, 2015
MAUNA KEA RULES TO STOP PROTECTORS RULED ILLEGAL
Hawai`i News Now - October 10, 2015
A state judge has invalidated the emergency rules that made it illegal to be on Mauna Kea at night.
The state Board of Land and Natural Resources approved the rules in July after activists opposed to the Thirty Meter Telescope blocked the road in an effort to stop its construction at the summit.
The motion was granted Friday afternoon by Big Island Circuit Judge Ronald Ibarra.
David Kauila Kopper, an attorney with the Native Hawaiian Legal Corporation, filed the lawsuit challenging the rules on behalf of E. Kalani Flores. "The court recognized that the state did not follow the rule of law in creating these emergency rules," Kopper said in a statement. "The state can no longer arrest innocent people who are on Mauna Kea at night for cultural or spiritual reasons."
"The state adopted an illegal rule to prevent opposition to the TMT at the expense of sincere cultural practices and public expression," said Kopper. "Cultural practitioners, like Professor Flores, and the public should not have been put in the impossible position of choosing between giving up their nighttime practices on Mauna Kea or becoming a criminal."
"They were privileged rules slapped together in an effort to target our specific right to openly protest, to openly protect our sacred places, our natural resources," said Aloha Aina activist Lanakila Mangauil.
The state said the rules were necessary after activists moved rocks and boulders onto the summit road and DLNR agents were forced to turn everyone around because of concerns for public safety.
A total of 15 people have been arrested since the rule took effect. But one of those arrested said it's still unclear exactly how the judge's decision will affect them.
Hawai`i News Now - October 10, 2015
A state judge has invalidated the emergency rules that made it illegal to be on Mauna Kea at night.
The state Board of Land and Natural Resources approved the rules in July after activists opposed to the Thirty Meter Telescope blocked the road in an effort to stop its construction at the summit.
The motion was granted Friday afternoon by Big Island Circuit Judge Ronald Ibarra.
David Kauila Kopper, an attorney with the Native Hawaiian Legal Corporation, filed the lawsuit challenging the rules on behalf of E. Kalani Flores. "The court recognized that the state did not follow the rule of law in creating these emergency rules," Kopper said in a statement. "The state can no longer arrest innocent people who are on Mauna Kea at night for cultural or spiritual reasons."
"The state adopted an illegal rule to prevent opposition to the TMT at the expense of sincere cultural practices and public expression," said Kopper. "Cultural practitioners, like Professor Flores, and the public should not have been put in the impossible position of choosing between giving up their nighttime practices on Mauna Kea or becoming a criminal."
"They were privileged rules slapped together in an effort to target our specific right to openly protest, to openly protect our sacred places, our natural resources," said Aloha Aina activist Lanakila Mangauil.
The state said the rules were necessary after activists moved rocks and boulders onto the summit road and DLNR agents were forced to turn everyone around because of concerns for public safety.
A total of 15 people have been arrested since the rule took effect. But one of those arrested said it's still unclear exactly how the judge's decision will affect them.
Tuesday, October 06, 2015
Saturday, September 26, 2015
Thursday, September 24, 2015
"NO INHERENT RIGHT TO DEVELOP
MAUNA KEA"
The Conversation - September 20, 2015
Plans to build a new telescope on Mauna Kea in Hawai'i have led to months of protests and arrests, including several earlier this month. The ongoing protest pitches astronomers against Hawaiians wanting to protect their sacred site.
Conflict between Indigenous and Western interests are part of a long history of colonisation and exploitation. In the Amazon, indigenous communities are fighting governments that exploit the rain forest for natural resources. In the United States and Canada, First Nations people are battling mining and oil interests.
In Western Australia, Aboriginal people are finding their 30,000 year old rock art sites being deregistered as sacred because they must be “devoted to a religious use” rather than be “a place subject to mythological story, song, or belief”. Many of these sites are in areas of industrial expansion.
If the traditional custodians of the land reject proposals for development, they might face aggressive legal action.
“No” is rarely a good enough answer for those exploiting the land, and seeking permission from indigenous people often smacks of tokenism rather than a real attempt to address the wrongs of the past.
On Hawai'i’s Big Island stands Mauna Kea, a dormant volcano towering 4,200 meters above sea level. Its high elevation and excellent atmospheric conditions make it an ideal place for astronomers to observe the stars. Mauna Kea is named for the god Wakea, the “sky father” – Mauna a Wakea. It is Hawai'i’s most sacred place.
It is important to note here that only people of Indigenous Polynesian Hawaiian heritage are called “Hawaiian”. Non-Indigenous people born in Hawai'i are called “Kama'aina” meaning “child of the land”, or “people of Hawaii” in general conversation.
Hawaiian reverence for Wakea meant that in ancient traditions only the Ali'i (high chiefs) were allowed to climb to its summit, where their most sacred ancestors are buried. It is here that astronomers plan to build a US$1.5-billion telescope with a primary mirror measuring 30 meters across.
The TMT offers potential scientific discoveries as well as economic benefits for the island. Currently there are 13 telescopes atop Mauna Kea but many Hawaiians are angry about the push to add more telescopes to the mountain, insisting enough is enough.
A resurgence of Hawaiian culture and language has led to the reclamation of sacred sites, including Mauna Kea, as areas of high cultural significance. Hawaiians wanting to preserve their cultural heritage are now clashing with proponents of the TMT. In recent months, protesters have blocked access to the mountain, halting development of the telescope.
It is disheartening and frustrating to witness fellow scientists dismiss the connections indigenous people have to their land. We cannot simply disregard these connections as myths and legends, and comparing TMT protesters to Biblical Creationists is disappointing.
This is not a battle between religion and science. Hawaiians are not anti-science; they are not trying to push their traditional beliefs on others nor are they trying to stifle scientific and economic advancement. They simply oppose construction of yet another telescope on their sacred mountain.
We need to recognise and respect the close connection Hawaiians have to sacred sites like Mauna Kea and not misappropriate Hawaiian astronomical traditions for the benefit of astronomers.
The TMT demonstrates a microcosm of the challenges indigenous people face when their traditions are dismissed by Western interests for intellectual or economic gain.
We do not have a convenient solution to this issue. So how do we move forward together?
We can look at successful collaborations between scientists and indigenous people on other projects for guidance. The development of the Square Kilometre Array radio telescope in Western Australia was a result of close collaboration and ongoing consultation between astronomers and the traditional owners of the land.
We can take inspiration from the Polynesian Voyaging Society and Hoku'lea – the Hawaiian voyaging canoe. By working closely with artisans, navigators, astronomers, and historians, Hawaiians are reclaiming their ancient knowledge and in turn are sharing this with the world.
These two examples suggest nurturing mutually respectful relationships is the key to overcoming conflict.
This is a highly complex issue. We astronomers need to acknowledge that we do not have an inherent right to develop Mauna Kea. And if a consensus cannot be reached we must be willing to consider a different home for the TMT.
MAUNA KEA"
The Conversation - September 20, 2015
Plans to build a new telescope on Mauna Kea in Hawai'i have led to months of protests and arrests, including several earlier this month. The ongoing protest pitches astronomers against Hawaiians wanting to protect their sacred site.
Conflict between Indigenous and Western interests are part of a long history of colonisation and exploitation. In the Amazon, indigenous communities are fighting governments that exploit the rain forest for natural resources. In the United States and Canada, First Nations people are battling mining and oil interests.
In Western Australia, Aboriginal people are finding their 30,000 year old rock art sites being deregistered as sacred because they must be “devoted to a religious use” rather than be “a place subject to mythological story, song, or belief”. Many of these sites are in areas of industrial expansion.
If the traditional custodians of the land reject proposals for development, they might face aggressive legal action.
“No” is rarely a good enough answer for those exploiting the land, and seeking permission from indigenous people often smacks of tokenism rather than a real attempt to address the wrongs of the past.
The mountain of Wakea
Unfortunately, it is not just economic interests that put pressure on indigenous communities. Scientific interests prove another challenge to indigenous land rights. One such case is the development of the Thirty Meter Telescope (TMT) in Hawai'i.On Hawai'i’s Big Island stands Mauna Kea, a dormant volcano towering 4,200 meters above sea level. Its high elevation and excellent atmospheric conditions make it an ideal place for astronomers to observe the stars. Mauna Kea is named for the god Wakea, the “sky father” – Mauna a Wakea. It is Hawai'i’s most sacred place.
It is important to note here that only people of Indigenous Polynesian Hawaiian heritage are called “Hawaiian”. Non-Indigenous people born in Hawai'i are called “Kama'aina” meaning “child of the land”, or “people of Hawaii” in general conversation.
Hawaiian reverence for Wakea meant that in ancient traditions only the Ali'i (high chiefs) were allowed to climb to its summit, where their most sacred ancestors are buried. It is here that astronomers plan to build a US$1.5-billion telescope with a primary mirror measuring 30 meters across.
The TMT offers potential scientific discoveries as well as economic benefits for the island. Currently there are 13 telescopes atop Mauna Kea but many Hawaiians are angry about the push to add more telescopes to the mountain, insisting enough is enough.
A resurgence of Hawaiian culture and language has led to the reclamation of sacred sites, including Mauna Kea, as areas of high cultural significance. Hawaiians wanting to preserve their cultural heritage are now clashing with proponents of the TMT. In recent months, protesters have blocked access to the mountain, halting development of the telescope.
An ongoing concern
Should astronomers be allowed to build the TMT on Mauna Kea? This question raises concerns that we, as practising astronomers, see as a reoccurring issue within the scientific community.It is disheartening and frustrating to witness fellow scientists dismiss the connections indigenous people have to their land. We cannot simply disregard these connections as myths and legends, and comparing TMT protesters to Biblical Creationists is disappointing.
This is not a battle between religion and science. Hawaiians are not anti-science; they are not trying to push their traditional beliefs on others nor are they trying to stifle scientific and economic advancement. They simply oppose construction of yet another telescope on their sacred mountain.
We need to recognise and respect the close connection Hawaiians have to sacred sites like Mauna Kea and not misappropriate Hawaiian astronomical traditions for the benefit of astronomers.
The TMT demonstrates a microcosm of the challenges indigenous people face when their traditions are dismissed by Western interests for intellectual or economic gain.
Moving forward together
We acknowledge that some Hawaiians do in fact support the TMT, while others are calling for the removal of all telescopes. Governor David Ige offered one compromise: the removal of a quarter of the existing telescopes before building of the TMT commences.We do not have a convenient solution to this issue. So how do we move forward together?
We can look at successful collaborations between scientists and indigenous people on other projects for guidance. The development of the Square Kilometre Array radio telescope in Western Australia was a result of close collaboration and ongoing consultation between astronomers and the traditional owners of the land.
We can take inspiration from the Polynesian Voyaging Society and Hoku'lea – the Hawaiian voyaging canoe. By working closely with artisans, navigators, astronomers, and historians, Hawaiians are reclaiming their ancient knowledge and in turn are sharing this with the world.
These two examples suggest nurturing mutually respectful relationships is the key to overcoming conflict.
This is a highly complex issue. We astronomers need to acknowledge that we do not have an inherent right to develop Mauna Kea. And if a consensus cannot be reached we must be willing to consider a different home for the TMT.
Tuesday, September 22, 2015
Monday, September 14, 2015
Saturday, September 12, 2015
Thursday, September 10, 2015
Tuesday, September 01, 2015
Saturday, August 29, 2015
Friday, August 28, 2015
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)














